Burning Godzilla vs Fire Godzilla, who wins and why?

It's not controversy, it's just a friendly discussion. It's the whole point. Are we we're screaming it at each other or meaning any offense? No! We're just talking about who we think would win lol

well I like both Heisei Burning Godzilla and Monsterverse Burning Godzilla

*controversy screaming* 

Fire Godzilla's body temperature, or at least the area around him was heated to 1370 degrees celsius

Close-range with quick kill, Burning Godzilla 2019 (Or as you still call it, Fire Godzilla. [Even though it is officially called Burning Godzilla.]) would win because he is a better and faster melee fighter.

But outside of the case mentioned above, long-range, and/or overall, Burning Godzilla 1995 wins because his Infinite Heat Ray increases with every nuclear pulse he does, and combined with 2019 adding to 1995's radiation, he will blast 2019 with what I would call a "Super Infinite Heat Ray", which would definitely kill 2019, and then shortly after defeating him, 1995 would then explode and engulf the entire world in a nuclear bomb-like explosion that hasn't been seen since the extinction of the dinosaurs 65 million years ago that wiped out 75% of all life on Earth (the famous K-T Extinction), or possibly even the Permian Mass Extinction of 250 million years ago that wiped out 90% of all life on Earth (the less famous but more deadly Great Dying), taking out just as many as the former, or even the latter.

And that's why I think Burning Godzilla 1995 will win over Burning Godzilla 2019. (Or as you call him, Fire Godzilla.)

Fire Godzilla DOES have increased durability compared to his base state which is already comparable to standard Heisei Godzilla and presumably Burning Godzilla who isn't stated to have better durability.

However, the Infinite Heat Ray and regeneration are definitely a factor. With the amount of radiation being thrown around, neither side will be going down easy.

The pulses from Fire Godzilla are certainly stronger than any from Burning Godzilla, but we haven't seen him use an Atomic Breath attack in that form. It could be a simple case of Fire Godzilla using his overall superior physical abilities to get Burning Godzilla down to beat on him, but it also could easily become a case of the Infinite Heat Ray becoming too much.

It's a close match for sure.

Fire Godzilla because he can survive going thermonuclear but burning can't he would just meltdown and fire would eventually outlast and survive go back to his standard state then during burnings meltdown he could just absorb all the radiation go thermonuclear again then eventually go back to his standard state again.

I'm calling Burning Godzilla 2019 Fire Godzilla just to differentiate the two.

It's a moot point since both versions were somewhat neutralized before they went went full "thermonuclear". Burning Godzilla's radiation was absorbed by Junior and Fire Godzilla had Mothra's life force to help contain his full force. But you do realize we are talking about fictional characters and situations here, right? ;)

KoldWarKid62,
It's the stigma of fantasy battles. Who wins? Whoever's writing the fight.

Kamoebas V.6,
I think you need to differentiate between what a debate and a flame war is. If everyone agreed, then what's the point of asking the question?

One was going to blow up and destroy the planet and one was going to destroy Boston. Seems the power levels are on different scales here.

Could yall continue this on the actual FIGHT thread please?

For the people saying "he was gonna blow up the planet", do bear in mind that's not his actual level of power. That's his LOSE condition, and also the lose condition for the planet.

He wasn't planet busting or anything to that effect; he was simply going to meltdown, causing a chain reaction that would've destroyed the Earth.

Ergo, as any good VS. debater would know, this is not a valid interpretation of his strength.

also the "he was gonna blow up the planet", could have well been an over exaggeration

Ergo, as any good VS. debater would know, this is not a valid interpretation of his strength.

Lol.

"also the "he was gonna blow up the planet", could have well been an over exaggeration"

Then why bother writing it into the script?

Because it makes for good drama.

Contextual clues, friends. The simulation was of him melting down, with the ensuing heat melting through the layers of the Earth down into the core, causing a chain reaction that would make the Earth blow up.

Yes, he was gonna destroy the planet. No, this was not a level of power he was displaying in combat and in fact very specifically was the end result upon his death if his meltdown stage wasn't halted or lessened.

Now, can we get back to the debate at hand?

well its been 5 years since I last watched Godzilla vs Destoroyah and I only watched the movie once so forgive me if my memory is very fuzzy on a lot of the details. All I remember from that movie was Destoroyah was awesome looking and parts of it reminded me of Aliens and Godzilla became Burning Godzilla and died with Godzilla Junior's revival.

You know, seeing all these responses, I'm actually surprised no-one said anything about my response.

Well, people ignoring you is VERY prominent here. 

I have way too much experience with that.