Godzilla vs Smaug

man godzilla will win in a second. godzilla is bigger and there both lizards but there is so much that i dont know about smaug. to be honest i didnt see the hobbit trailer. at the end of the fight godzilla will win because he is almost invencable.

Read the book and saw the movie, Smaug is awesome but doesn't stand a chance. Godzilla wins.

haha. that is a hilarious question. seriously though, even a black hole gun couldn't stop godzilla, smaug wouldn't stand a chance. think of it as a t.rex vs a komodo, the komod is pretty cool, and its tough, but its nothing to the t.rex. besides, smaug can't compare with king ghidorah.

smaug is pretty cool though.

if you had been asking about the big iguana from tristars godzilla i would route for smaug, i hate that lizard thing.

All put it to you this way Godzilla killed an alien that woke up after 60 million years & with all that advance technology & strategy it had to take Godzillas DNA & conquer the world, Godzilla destroyed Orga the very next day & not a scratch was left on him. And then he went about his buisness, to finish destroying Japan. (Just another day at the office for Godzilla) LOL!!!

I love the Smaug in the movie, but I have to go Godzilla because his much bigger and more powerful.

Sorry to say that Godzilla would win, now if it was the 1998 Zilla then we might have a different battle. I have heard of, in a book who's story is well before "The Hobbit" of Ancalagon the Black; a mountain sized Dragon! However, I see Smaug as the better dragon for he was smart enough to lay on his hoard for centuries, forming a diamond coat to protect the vulnerable underbelly. However, Ancalagon would have bigger muscles and hotter fire power than Smaug. Now I haven't seen, nor care to, the Desolation of Smaug movie because they got his look all wrong. Here is Tolkien's original Smaug drawing when asked what he looked like

Here is a fan creation, can't remember who, of a baby Smaug I found...

...and here is a fan's (not mine) re-creation of Tolkien's depiction of Smaug (which is what I had hoped the movie version would have, and not a "weak wyvern")

godzilla but mostly because i assume he would throw smaug in the air like kaiser ghidorah and super heat ray him and boom. then he kills the goblin and orcs but then he go back to the ocean

Tolkien fans such as I have been calculating the exact measurements of Smaug since Part 1 released last year; trust me, if we're talking 2014 Godzilla, there'd be no contest. The only thing Smaug has that could help against Godzilla is his cunning and intelligence, but size alone makes it quick loss in his favor. Funny though, I posted about this question on Tumblr the other day and get the same responses, haha.

The comparison to sizes is a bit to far to be considered fair. Smaug would be a fly to Godzilla. I always thought it funny that they considered him a dinosaur in a lot of those old movies. He was way to big to ba a dinosaur. Even the big dinosaur in the third Jurassic Park would have been a bug to be squashed by Godzilla. All you can say about Godzilla is that he was a freak of nature created by radiation fall out, and nothing to do with fossils or dinosaurs or anything from the prehistoric age. Even the original King Kong was about a third of his size, although they made him bigger for that one movie, but if you see the original 1930's movie and the new one by Peter Jackson. He is about one third the size of Godzilla.

I think you all are underestimating Smaug's size, or overestimating Godzilla's size. In the movie, he seems to be about 150 feet long, which is just about the same size as the original Godzilla and several Millenium incarnations. He'd still be curbstomped by Godzilla, but not because of size, like everyone's been saying, but because of their abilities:

Smaug's Abilities:

-Ordinary fire breath.

-Immunity to Medieval conventional weapons (e.g. swords and arrows).

-Flight.

Godzilla's Abilities:

-Thermonuclear fire breath.

-Immunity to modern conventional weapons (e.g. tanks and missiles) and alien/futuristic weapons (e.g. lasers and), and, in some incarnations, things like nukes, meteors, and even black holes.

-Wolverine-like regeneration.