Godzilla Minus One 2, Supernova and Monarch news

23 years ago today, Roland Emmerich's Godzilla hit theaters. Have your opinions changed since then?

Godzilla-Movies.com/forum/
Poll
9183 Views22 Replies
Do you still resent Godzilla 1998 or has the film grown on you over time?

Chris

AdminSpaceGodzillaMay-21-2021 1:54 PM

23 years ago today, on May 20th 1998 Roland Emmerich's Godzilla released in theaters. Sparking massive controversy amongst the Godzilla fan community, this film often gets a lot of hate simply for being called Godzilla. None of Godzilla's trademark characteristics were used and Tristar seemingly didn't care to honor the original source material and attempted to re-invent the iconic movie monster for a western audience.

Although it cleared about $370 million at the box office at the time, the film fell short on many levels. As an unrelated giant monster movie it was actually quite enjoyable, but as a Godzilla movie, it failed. The animated series which it spawned redeemed the Zilla marginally but ultimately didn't do the King of Monsters the justice he deserves.

After 23 years, have your opinions changed? Do you like the 1998 Godzilla more after all this time? Or do you still resent the title for its portrayal of Godzilla? Sound off below and let us know!

Personally, I'll watch the film and enjoy it for what it is - a Kaiju movie - but I still don't consider it a worthy or recognizable addition to the Godzilla cinematic legacy.

Predator: Badlands - coming November 7th, 2025

User Avatar
Djdndnejwnwn
Group: Member
Rank: Gigan
View Profile

I mean, I wasn’t alive....?
Well I used to like it, but now.... no

expecting the worst, sets you up for thr worst

User Avatar
Djdndnejwnwn
Group: Member
Rank: Gigan
View Profile

Chris

Can indifferent be an option?

expecting the worst, sets you up for thr worst

User Avatar
G. H. (Gman)
Group: Admin
Rank: Godzilla
View Profile

"Resent," is a bit strong. It's just a bad movie, Godzilla in its title or not.

The thing I resent is that an entire studio put the property in the hands of people that had aggressive contempt for the material and avidly tried to make something that was as least like the source material as possible. There was no love in this movie. Emmerich didn't even want to make it. It's summed perfectly by Co-Executive Producer Robert N. Fried:

“There was no understanding of the property and what it was all about. The Sony executive team that took over Godzilla was one of the worst cases of executive incompetence I have observed in my twenty year career. One of the golden assets of our time, which was hand-delivered to them, was managed as poorly and ineptly as anybody can manage an asset. They took a jewel and turned it into dust.”

"'Nostalgic' does not equal 'good,' and 'standards' does not equal 'elitism.'" "Being offended is inevitable. Living offended is your choice."
User Avatar
Djdndnejwnwn
Group: Member
Rank: Gigan
View Profile

I mean, I don’t really have much of an opinion on it. I haven’t really bothered to watch it recently so it’s been a while

expecting the worst, sets you up for thr worst

User Avatar
Djdndnejwnwn
Group: Member
Rank: Gigan
View Profile

G. H. (Gman)

And the obnoxious advertising. 

expecting the worst, sets you up for thr worst

User Avatar
Kattozilla
Group: Member
Rank: Anguirus
View Profile

TACO BELL

i've actually never resented it. i've always liked it since i first saw it sooo-

i've officially left. thanks for the memories!
User Avatar
Chris
Group: Admin
Rank: SpaceGodzilla
View Profile

Added indifferent as an option!

@Gman, yeah I recall their attempt with Godzilla was the give the creature a completely new face and origin to be more modern. Unfortunately they missed the point of Godzilla's existence entirely. They went for flashy, sleek designs and convenient plot elements that a child could comprehend. They went for the money, that's why they hired Emmerich on to direct it. Shame they missed the mark so dramatically.

Predator: Badlands - coming November 7th, 2025

User Avatar
Djdndnejwnwn
Group: Member
Rank: Gigan
View Profile

Chris 

thanks

expecting the worst, sets you up for thr worst

User Avatar
Kattozilla
Group: Member
Rank: Anguirus
View Profile

yes but

TACO BELL

i've officially left. thanks for the memories!
User Avatar
Djdndnejwnwn
Group: Member
Rank: Gigan
View Profile

i actually like taco bell, but i hate advertising that’s everywhere

expecting the worst, sets you up for thr worst

User Avatar
Trash panda
Group: Member
Rank: Anguirus
View Profile

It was the first Godzilla film I saw in 2011 when I was either 7 or 6. And I still don't like it.

Ah shit I’m using my wrong eye again. Sorry that was meant to be behind your back
User Avatar
Kattozilla
Group: Member
Rank: Anguirus
View Profile

TACO BEEEEEEELL

but yeah i've never really hated it. i actually unironically like it

is that bad

i've officially left. thanks for the memories!
User Avatar
Djdndnejwnwn
Group: Member
Rank: Gigan
View Profile

I say i’m indifferent because last time I saw it, didn’t hate it, didn’t live it, Just sort of Existed for two hours

expecting the worst, sets you up for thr worst

User Avatar
Djdndnejwnwn
Group: Member
Rank: Gigan
View Profile

Kattozilla

I’ve seen that commercial

expecting the worst, sets you up for thr worst

User Avatar
Djdndnejwnwn
Group: Member
Rank: Gigan
View Profile

IM GONNA NEED A BIGGER BALL.

Here lizard lizard. 

I mean, what where they thinking?

expecting the worst, sets you up for thr worst

User Avatar
Die-hard Spino Fan
Group: Member
Rank: Baragon
View Profile

Can “love it” be an option? Because it’s amazing. I like it a lot. 4/5

That is one big pile of shit - Ian Malcom, 1993
User Avatar
Kattozilla
Group: Member
Rank: Anguirus
View Profile

taco bell, that's what

chihuahua is the only one who can defeat godzilla

 

i've officially left. thanks for the memories!
User Avatar
Monsterzero9
Group: Member
Rank: Anguirus
View Profile

i personnoly just hate this film. even if i dont veiw it as a godzilla movie i still hate it. the acting is horendos and the jurassic park insparations are just to obvios. its just a downright bad movie in my book. 1/777456354237964653586

"Do you love it that much? That... monster graveyard?"
User Avatar
Die-hard Spino Fan
Group: Member
Rank: Baragon
View Profile

I never viewed this film as a Godzilla movie, not even once. I think that’s why I liked it. I watched it after I watched 2014 so I knew it was and never will be a Godzilla film. I treated it like any other big monster film. 

That is one big pile of shit - Ian Malcom, 1993
User Avatar
SasquaDash
Group: Member
Rank: Anguirus
View Profile

Honestly, I always enjoyed the movie, mainly due to nostalgia (it played a big role in my childhood). It was the first giant monster movie I ever saw. I had quite a bit of toys from the movie, some of which I still have (a couple of the babies and a Taco bell figure) and some that sadly did not last (particularly a 3D eraser and a "Power Blast Godzilla" remote control figure). It was the movie that helped make me the Godzilla/Monster movie fan I am Today, so I could never dislike it.

Was it a faithful Godzilla movie? No.

Was it a good movie? Not particularly.

Is it an enjoyable movie. In a ways, Yes. 

I think the movie had some cool ideas. The idea of a giant monster laying hundreds of eggs and the fear that these creatures could continue to multiply to the point that they could become the dominant species, wiping out humanity and other creatures, is kind of a cool premise. The problem was that it didn't fit Godzilla.

To be honest, I actually think that the first 30 minutes of the movie is really good. It does a great job at building up the creature and setting a somewhat mysterious tone. However, the movie starts to fall apart after the creature itself is revealed and you realize that it's not the true Godzilla. Ironically the movie starts out really similar to the 1954 film, a group of fishing ships are attacked, one of the survivors links the disaster to an old legend of  a sea monster known as "Gojira", and there's even a scene where the creature comes ashore at a village with the military investigating the aftermath of the attack and finding giant radioactive footprints (which if you look on Google Earth/Maps those footprints are still there on Kualoa Ranch). 

Honestly, after 23 years, I don't think it deserves the hate anymore. it was a massive misfire, I get why fans were outraged at the time, but constantly throwing hatred at it now is kind of pointless. And I don't think it's fair to criticize it for being different especially now, considering how different and experimental some of the more recent Toho entries are (Seriously, I'd take a mutant iguana laying eggs over a metallic plant thing that barely does anything). And at least some of the people involved, have admitted to their mistakes, unlike the crew behind a certain anime trilogy who continue to show distain for the fandom, insulting them for not being "smart enough" to get it, and viewing themselves as above the franchise... but I'm not here to rant about that. 

Overall, while the fanbase can still dislike the film, I don't think that it still deserves the hate. It happened, it's been 23, it's time to get over it.

"Neither beast nor man. Something monstrous."

Join the discussion!



Latest Media
Community Stats
This Godzilla Movie community is part of the Scified network. Scified hosts a network of online fan-site communities containing 406,413 posts by 48,450 members (15 are online now). The Shin-Gojira Forum is the most recently active forum. The latest Forum topic added was: Saw the 4K remaster of Shin Godzilla in theatres! Makes me want a sequel.
VIPWhat are VIP?AdminModeratorSpecial TitleMember
Join the discussion!
Please sign in to access your profile features!
(Signing in also removes ads!)



Forgot Password?
Scified Website LogoYour sci-fi community, old-school & modern
Hosted Fansites
AlienFansite
GodzillaFansite
PredatorFansite
Main Menu
Community
Sci-Fi Movies
Help & Info
+

Sign In to contribute!